Buffin Muffin Mystery Flavor
Our Buffin Secret Menu Mystery Week runs May 11 through May 15, with one mystery muffin unlocking each day as part of a limited-time secret menu event shared through Instagram Stories and swipe links.
You can expect a mix of throwback-style drops and surprise releases, with the biggest mystery reveal saved for Day 5.
To join in, shop on the website, start a new cart, add at least $50 in items, then use the popup to add a mystery muffin to your order, with limited stock and up to 3 adds max from the popup only.
Label note: The net weight on the labels are required by Long Island Weights & Measures. It doesn’t reflect calories or macros. Your nutrition info comes from the recipe and the measured scoops of each ingredient, not how heavy the container is. Since foods can hold a little more or less water, the weight may change slightly, but the calories and macros stay the same.
Must be refrigerated. Can freeze up to 3 months.
Shipping costs $19.99 or $29.99 depending on your location and special packaging. Some states require 2-day shipping. If ground shipping isn’t shown, it may be due to your location or timing. Orders process within 24-48 hours before shipping.












